When the College Football Playoff Selection Committee unveiled its Week 13 rankings on Tuesday, November 18, 2025, at the Gaylord Texan Resort & Convention Center in Grapevine, Texas, one name stayed stubbornly in place: Texas A&M University. The Aggies, undefeated at 10-0, clung to No. 3 — a position they’ve held since November 11 — despite not playing a single snap that weekend. Meanwhile, chaos erupted above and below them. University of Alabama lost its grip on the top five after a shocking 23-21 home defeat to University of Oklahoma at Bryant-Denny Stadium in Tuscaloosa. And University of Georgia surged past them, thanks to a dominant 35-10 win over University of Texas in Austin. The result? A top five that looks nothing like it did a week ago.
Alabama’s fall to No. 10 — despite matching Oklahoma’s 8-2 record — wasn’t just about the loss. It was about perception. The committee saw the Crimson Tide’s schedule as softer, their wins less impressive, and their home defeat to Oklahoma as a fatal blow. Meanwhile, Oklahoma’s win vaulted them to No. 8, their highest ranking since 2019. "It’s not just the loss," said one anonymous committee member in a post-release briefing. "It’s what you do after. Alabama didn’t look like a team ready to win a national title on December 20. Georgia did. Texas A&M did."
That’s a seismic shift. In 2023, University of Cincinnati was left out despite a perfect season. This year, Tulane’s 9-2 record — including wins over Houston and UCF — was enough. "It’s fair," said Robert Behrens, staff writer for Good Bull Hunting. "The system rewards winning your conference. That’s what college football is supposed to be about."
Even more surprising: Brigham Young (9-1) and Utah (8-2) both received votes — a sign that the committee is taking the Mountain West more seriously than ever. Meanwhile, Texas (7-3) and Tennessee (7-3) were out of the conversation. The Aggies? They’re still in control.
And then there’s the SEC Championship. On December 6, 2025, at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta, Georgia will face Texas — not just for the conference title, but for a shot at the national title. If Georgia wins, they’ll likely jump Texas A&M. If they lose? The Aggies could be the highest-ranked one-loss team in the country.
"This isn’t about rankings," said David Cobb of CBS Sports. "It’s about momentum. Texas A&M has it. Alabama lost theirs. Georgia found theirs. That’s what the committee sees."
For Texas A&M, this is their best shot at a national title since 2012. For the SEC, it’s a chance to prove they still dominate college football. For the rest? It’s a reminder that in the new era, every win matters — and every loss can be fatal.
The CFP Selection Committee values consistency and strength of schedule over recent activity. Texas A&M’s perfect 10-0 record, combined with wins over ranked opponents like LSU and Florida, gave them enough weight to hold their position even without a game. Their schedule rating was higher than Georgia’s, and Alabama’s loss to Oklahoma hurt their resume more than Texas A&M’s bye helped anyone else.
Under the 12-team format’s rules, the highest-ranked champion from a Group of Five conference gets an automatic bid — regardless of overall ranking. Tulane won the American Athletic Conference with a 9-2 record, including wins over ranked Houston and UCF. Even at No. 24, they were the highest-ranked non-Power Five champ, making them the 12th and final team in the field.
The committee prioritizes quality wins and schedule difficulty. Oklahoma’s win over Alabama — a top-five team on the road — was a massive resume boost. Alabama’s loss at home to a team that finished 8-2, combined with weaker wins over teams like Mississippi State and Arkansas, dragged them down. The committee saw Oklahoma as the stronger team.
Win their final game against South Carolina on November 23, and hope Georgia loses to Texas in the SEC Championship. If Georgia wins, they’ll likely pass Texas A&M due to head-to-head tiebreakers and stronger conference performance. But if the Aggies finish 11-0 and Georgia drops one, A&M will be the top one-loss team — and likely stay at No. 3 or even rise.
Miami is the highest-ranked champion of the Atlantic Coast Conference. Michigan, despite being 8-2, didn’t win the Big Ten. Conference championship wins are weighted heavily in the 12-team format. Miami’s win over Clemson and strong non-conference schedule gave them the edge over Michigan’s losses to Ohio State and Penn State — even though Michigan’s overall record was better.
Before 2024, Texas Tech would’ve been a long shot for any playoff consideration. Now, with a 10-1 record and a win over Oklahoma, they’re the first non-Power Five team to crack the top five under the new rules. They’re not just in the conversation — they’re hosting a playoff game. That’s historic. It’s also a sign that the committee is now evaluating teams on merit, not conference pedigree.
Hi, I'm Landon Hawthorne and I'm a sports enthusiast with a passion for writing about all things athletic. My expertise in sports allows me to provide in-depth analysis, exciting play-by-play commentary, and thought-provoking opinion pieces to engage readers. I have covered various sports events locally and internationally, always striving to bring a fresh perspective to my audience. In my free time, you can find me participating in sports activities or discussing the latest games with fellow fans.
View all posts by: Landon Hawthorne